5 Factors to Consider When Engagement Ring Shopping: How to Choose the Perfect Ring10 min read

Picture of Choose Frugal

Choose Frugal


This article may include affiliate links. View the disclosure for more information.

Factors to Consider When Engagement Ring Shopping. Man putting ring on woman's finger.Shopping for an engagement ring is an exciting and significant milestone on your marriage journey. However, with a plethora of options available, it can be overwhelming to navigate the choices and find the perfect ring for your partner.

This article will explore several key considerations when shopping for engagement rings to help you choose the perfect one to propose to your girlfriend.

What To Consider When Shopping for an Engagement Ring

When shopping for an engagement ring, there are many things to consider. However, it isn’t quite as straightforward as finding the first ring you like and buying it. And considering how expensive engagement rings are, you should take the time to ensure the ring is perfect. So, here are five factors to consider when engagement ring shopping.

1. Type of Stone:

Factors to Consider When Engagement Ring Shopping. Pink diamond ring.Regarding engagement rings, the type of stone you choose is a significant consideration. The stone serves as the centerpiece and can vary in terms of gemstone options. Here are some popular choices and their characteristics.


Diamonds have long been the traditional choice for engagement rings. Known for their brilliance and durability, diamonds are available in various cuts, colors, and clarities. They symbolize eternal love and are a timeless choice.


Gemstones offer a vibrant and personalized alternative to diamonds. Popular gemstone options include sapphires, emeralds, rubies, and morganites. Each gemstone has its unique color, meaning, and symbolism, allowing you to choose a stone that aligns with your partner’s style and preferences.


Moissanite is a lab-created gemstone that closely resembles a diamond. However, it offers exceptional brilliance and fire at a more affordable price point. Moissanite is popular for those seeking a diamond alternative with a similar visual appeal.

Consider your partner’s taste and style when choosing the type of stone for the engagement ring. Each stone has its own qualities and significance, allowing you to create a ring with special meaning and reflecting your partner’s individuality.

2. Metal Options

Engagement rings come in various metal options, each with its unique characteristics. Choosing the right metal for your partner’s engagement ring should be one of your top priorities.

Watch this video by Engage Studios to learn more about the different metals you can use for an engagement ring: How to Choose Your Engagement Ring Metal.

Here are some popular choices and their pros and cons:

Platinum: Platinum is a durable, hypoallergenic metal that naturally looks white and lustrous. It is highly resistant to tarnishing and corrosion. However, platinum can be more expensive than other metals due to its rarity.

Gold: Gold is a classic choice for engagement rings. It is available in different colors, including yellow, white, and rose gold. Gold is relatively more affordable compared to platinum. However, it is a softer metal and may require occasional maintenance to retain its shine.

Palladium: Palladium is a lightweight metal with a similar appearance to platinum but at a lower price point. It is hypoallergenic and resistant to tarnish. Palladium is a great option for those seeking the platinum look without the higher cost.

3. Natural vs. Lab-Grown Diamonds

Factors to Consider When Engagement Ring Shopping. MicroscopeChoosing between natural and lab-grown diamonds is a personal decision. Here’s a comparison to help you make an informed choice:

Natural Diamonds

Natural diamonds are formed deep within the Earth over millions of years. They have been the traditional choice for engagement rings for centuries. And while many people are looking at alternative stones for their engagement rings, natural diamonds continue to be a popular choice. Here are the pros and cons of natural diamonds.

Pros of Natural Diamonds

Rarity and Exclusivity: Natural diamonds are highly valued for their rarity and unique qualities. Their formation process takes millions of years, making them truly extraordinary.

Timeless Beauty: Natural diamonds possess a captivating beauty and charm that has stood the test of time. Many people appreciate the historical and sentimental significance associated with natural diamonds.

Investment Value: Natural diamonds have historically held their value and even appreciated over time, making them potential long-term investments.

Cons of Natural Diamonds

Ethical Concerns: The diamond industry has faced scrutiny regarding unethical mining practices, such as conflict diamonds (blood diamonds), sourced from regions associated with civil wars and human rights abuses. It’s crucial to ensure the ethical sourcing of natural diamonds by choosing those certified as conflict-free.

Environmental Impact: Diamond mining has environmental implications, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and carbon emissions. Responsible mining practices aim to mitigate these impacts, but they still exist to some extent.

Lab-Grown Diamonds

Lab-grown diamonds, also known as synthetic diamonds, are created in a controlled environment that simulates the natural diamond-growing process. They have the same physical, chemical, and optical properties as natural diamonds. Here are the pros and cons of lab-grown diamonds.

Pros of Lab-Grown Diamonds

Ethical and Conflict-Free: Lab-grown diamonds offer a conflict-free alternative to natural diamonds. They are produced in controlled lab conditions, eliminating concerns about human rights abuses associated with diamond mining.

Environmental Sustainability: Lab-grown diamonds have a significantly lower environmental impact than natural diamonds. They require fewer natural resources and do not contribute to habitat destruction or water pollution caused by mining.

Affordability: Lab-grown diamonds are generally more affordable than natural diamonds of similar quality. This allows for a larger stone or higher-quality diamond within a given budget.

Cons of Lab-Grown Diamonds

Perception and Sentimental Value: Some individuals may still value the historical significance and emotional attachment associated with natural diamonds. Lab-grown diamonds may hold a different sentimental value for those who appreciate diamonds’ natural rarity and uniqueness.

Limited Color Options: Currently, lab-grown diamonds are primarily available in colorless and near-colorless grades. Natural diamonds offer a broader range of colors, including fancy-colored diamonds.

Resale Value: Lab-grown diamonds have a different established resale market than natural diamonds. While their value has been stable, how the market will evolve in the long term is still being determined.

4. Considerations When Choosing a Stone for the Ring

Factors to Consider When Engagement Ring Shopping. DiamondsWhen selecting a stone for an engagement ring, several key factors come into play. Here are the important aspects to consider:

Cut: The cut of a diamond or gemstone refers to its proportions, symmetry, and polish. A well-cut stone reflects light beautifully, enhancing its sparkle and brilliance. Common cut styles include round brilliant, princess, cushion, emerald, and oval. Choose a cut that complements your partner’s style and maximizes the stone’s beauty.

Clarity: Clarity refers to the presence of internal and external characteristics, known as inclusions and blemishes, within a stone. The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) grades clarity on a scale from Flawless (no inclusions or blemishes visible under 10x magnification) to Included (inclusions visible to the naked eye). Select a clarity grade that strikes a balance between quality and budget.

Color: Diamonds and gemstones come in a variety of colors. While white diamonds are popular, colored gemstones such as sapphires, emeralds, and rubies offer unique alternatives. The GIA grades diamonds on a color scale from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow or brown). Choose a color grade that suits your partner’s preferences and desired aesthetic.

Carat Weight: Carat weight measures the size of a stone. It’s important to note that carat weight does not solely determine a stone’s value or beauty. Higher carat weight may come at a higher price. Still, other factors like cut, clarity, and color also influence a stone’s overall appearance. Consider your partner’s style and the overall balance of the ring when choosing the carat weight.

Certification: When purchasing a diamond, selecting one with a reputable grading report from a recognized gemological laboratory such as GIA or AGS is advisable. These reports provide detailed information about the stone’s characteristics, ensuring transparency and quality.

Remember, when considering these factors, finding the right balance that aligns with your partner’s preferences, budget, and desired aesthetic is crucial. Each aspect contributes to the overall beauty and value of the stone, making it a significant symbol of your commitment.

5. How to Measure Your Girlfriend’s Finger to Determine Her Ring Size

Factors to Consider When Engagement Ring Shopping. RingsDetermining your partner’s ring size can be challenging if you want to surprise the engagement. Here are a few strategies to help you find the right size:

Borrow a ring: Borrow one of the rings she wears on the ring finger and have it sized at a jeweler.

Trace the ring: Place one of her rings on a piece of paper and trace the inner and outer edges. This can be taken to a jeweler to determine the size.

Seek help from friends or family: Enlist the help of her close friends or family members who may know her ring size or can discreetly find out for you.

Use a ring sizing chart: Online ring sizing charts can provide an estimate based on her finger measurements.

Frequently Asked Questions About Engagement Ring Shopping

Factors to Consider When Engagement Ring Shopping. Three women with engagement rings.Considering the complexity of buying the perfect engagement ring, it’s only natural that you may have more questions about this topic. Here are five of the most frequently asked questions about engagement ring shopping and their answers.

How Much Should I Spend on an Engagement Ring?

The amount spent on an engagement ring is a personal decision and should be based on your financial situation and comfort level. Traditionally, the “two months’ salary” rule has been suggested, but it is not a hard and fast rule. Consider your budget and prioritize finding a ring that holds sentimental value and fits within your means.

How do I Choose the Right Ring Style for My Partner?

Choosing the right ring style requires observing and understanding your partner’s preferences. Take note of the jewelry they wear or ask their close friends and family for input. Consider factors such as their lifestyle, personal style, and any specific design elements they may have mentioned liking in the past.

Should I Prioritize the 4Cs When Selecting a Diamond?

The 4Cs are important factors to consider when selecting a diamond. Still, their priority may vary based on personal preferences and budget. Therefore, it’s recommended to strike a balance between the 4Cs to find a diamond that suits your partner’s style while considering other factors such as certification, overall ring design, and budget.

Is it Possible to Customize an Engagement Ring?

Many jewelers offer customization options to create a unique and personalized engagement ring. From selecting the stone, metal, and design details to incorporating engraving or specific elements, customization allows you to create a ring that reflects your partner’s individuality and your relationship.

How can I Ensure the Ring Will Fit My Partner’s Finger?

Measuring your partner’s ring size accurately can be done by using methods such as borrowing a ring, tracing an existing ring, seeking help from friends or family, or using online ring sizing charts. If you’re unsure, it’s better to go slightly larger than smaller, as rings can be resized by a professional jeweler if needed.

Remember, every engagement ring shopping journey is unique. Feel free to seek guidance from reputable jewelers who can provide personalized assistance and answer any additional questions you may have during the process.


Shopping for an engagement ring involves careful consideration of various factors. By understanding these aspects and considering your partner’s preferences, you can choose a ring that symbolizes your love and commitment in a meaningful and unforgettable way.

Thank you message.

Thank you so much for reading this article! Please see our other blogs for more wedding-related content, including the best places to shop for wedding rings.

15 Affordable Wedding Ceremony Ideas You’ll Love

How Many People Should I Invite to My Wedding on a Budget?

15 Best Places to Buy Wedding Rings: Online and In-Person

Best Wedding Reception Order of Events for Your Big Day (4 steps to planning)

5 Wedding Day Timeline Tips

10 Top Tips for Planning a Wedding on a Budget You’ll Love

15 Affordable Wedding Ceremony Ideas You’ll Love

10 Bible Verses for Weddings Couples Will Love

6 Bible Readings for Weddings You’ll Love

P.S. Want to know when our next post lands and get our free ebook on how to live frugally? Then click the link below.

Sign up here to claim your free ebook!

Search Be More with Less:

Don't miss an article.

Sign up below and receive simplicity-inspired articles delivered for free.
Scroll to Top
We use cookies in order to give you the best possible experience on our website. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies.